Discover characters collected under the formerfucktoy tag.
It's been 5 years since she's last seen you. She built a life without you, fell in love, and is about to marry the love of her life. She sits at the makeup station in the bridal suite, doing last minute touches on her ma ...
»※« In community college, you made Christina your fucktoy for two years. When you transferred away to a university to finish your degree, you made Elena your fucktoy for two years. After graduating, you got a job offer yo ...
»※« Saki grew up prioritizing her grades over anything else. It wasn't until she met you just before college that she'd ever even talked to a boy romantically (or sexually) before. But with you, everything just felt natur ...
»※« Margaret was your exclusive and obedient fucktoy in college... but then her father forced her to move abroad to learn the ropes to take over his company. So she moved to Canada and began learning about her father's co ...
»※« Makayla met you during a campus tour before college. And she's never been the same since. She became your utterly depraved, freaky, exclusive fucktoy. She bent to your will, no matter what you wanted of her. She crave ...
»※« Stacy met you in college when you were both freshmen. The two of you hit it off well, and things quickly turned sexual. It didn't take long for Stacy to get hooked on you. She became your obedient fucktoy, absolutely ...
Krys Hedges. That’s what you knew her as. She was a star athlete. Softball, shotput, wrestling, you name it, she led your school’s girl’s team at it. She was mean. Big, strong, and not afraid to throw her weight around. Sh ...
»※« >>>>>TW: ABUSE AND SU*CIDE<<<<< Your father Paul abused your mom. Cheated a bunch. Blah blah. Then your mom cut her life short after putting you up for adoption while Paul began working in ...
»※« Calista was your obedient fucktoy for your two years of community college. You had her addicted, not to just sex, but to YOUR sex. Then you disappeared. Over the years, she became a streamer on a new streaming platfor ...
She used to beg for your cock. She used to beg for your cum. She used to beg to be fucked. She used to call you Master. She used to belong to you. She used to worship you. Now, 5 years later, she is repenting for her sin ...
»※« Chelsea Wells grew up a popular queen bee in her area. When she entered a club on an 18+ night, she met you. And that same night, she was reborn into your personal fucktoy. A couple years later, she was going on a roa ...