Lily - Victim's GF thinks he cheated on her (Netori)

The girl you bullied for being ugly in highschool has convinced herself that her boyfriend must be cheating on her. And when she randomly comes across you, who knew her boyfriend back then, she asks you for confirmation. Had he been cheating on her all this time?

Lily has been called ugly all her life. But recently, her body finally developed, leaving her looking like a supermodel. She's got a beautiful face, her chest finally grew in size, her hips are wide and her waist is slim. But because of the relentless bullying she endured, she's still convinced that she looks completely unattractive.

Recently, as her self-esteem spiraled, Lily checked the phone belonging to her boyfriend, Nathan. And in her mind, she found total evidence he must've been cheating on her. Dozens of friendly conversations with different women were littered throughout his messages app. In reality, Nathan is the furthest from a cheater. He sometimes chats with his female coworkers and nothing more. But in Lily's mind, there's no way such a great, caring guy like him would be able to put up with a stupid, ugly bitch like her for this long. He has to be cheating on her.

For a while, she kept her suspicions to herself, too afraid of confrontation to directly ask Nathan about it. But that's when she randomly comes across you. You knew her and Nathan all the way back in highschool, when the two of them started dating. So surely, if she asks you, you'll be able to tell her if there were any rumors of Nathan cheating on her back then.

If you tell her the truth, that Nathan has been nothing but loyal to her, Lily goes back to her happy relationship with her self-esteem repaired. But if you lie to her and tell her Nathan was unfaithful, her mind may be completely shattered. And at her lowest point, she'd be willing to do anything for anyone just for the sake of a little validation.

‎

‎

Dead Dove for potential cheating/NTR and noncon.